Released 09 May 2005  By Coalition for the Human Rights of Immigrants (CHRI)
On May 5, the House of Representatives voted 368-58 to approve the final version of an emergency supplemental appropriations bill, which includes a series of anti-immigrant measures originally introduced as the REAL ID Act [see INB 2/12/05, 4/3/05, 4/24/05]. The appropriations bill assigns about $76 billion for military operations, $656 million for tsunami relief, $4.2 billion for foreign aid and $635 million for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) bureaus of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customs and Border Protection (CBP). About $455 million goes for ICE to hire 50 criminal investigators and 168 immigration enforcement agents and deportation officers, and to obtain 1,950 additional detention beds. About $177 million goes to CBP to allow that agency to hire, train, equip and support 500 Border Patrol agents.
Although the Senate voted 99-0 on Apr. 21 for a version of the appropriations bill which excluded REAL ID, Senate leaders agreed in negotiations on May 3 to accept most of the REAL ID Act provisions in the final bill, supposedly in exchange for support of future immigration reform measures. The Senate is expected to approve the final version of the appropriations bill when it resumes sessions during the week of May 9.
The final bill requires applicants for state driver's licenses to show proof of citizenship or legal residency, document a home address and provide a photo ID. State motor vehicle departments would have to verify the documents using federal databases. States would have three years to comply with these requirements. If a state didn't comply, its licenses couldn't be used for federal identification purposes, such as boarding planes or entering federal buildings. [Associated Press 5/6/05; Los Angeles Times 5/6/05; Investor's Business Daily 5/6/05; Miami Herald 5/6/05; GovExec.com 5/5/05]
Some of the bill's controversial asylum provisions were modified in the final version. As passed, the Real ID Act will require applicants for asylum to prove that their race, religion, national origin, political opinion or membership in a particular social group constituted "at least one central reason" for their persecution. Current law requires applicants show that their persecution was based "at least in part" on one of these factors; the original version of REAL ID would have required applicants to prove that one of these factors was "a central reason" for their persecution.
Taken out of the final version of the bill were provisions eliminating stays of removal (which would have allowed asylum seekers to be deported while their cases are on appeal to federal court), giving bail bondspeople unprecedented power to detain immigrants in removal proceedings, and restricting judicial review of credibility determinations by immigration authorities. In a positive development, the Real ID Act removes the annual cap--presently 10,000--on the number of asylees who can adjust their status to permanent residency. [Immigration Equality 5/5/05; Latin America Working Group 5/6/05; ILW.com 5/6/05; Congressional Quarterly 5/4/05]
REAL ID gives the Secretary of Homeland Security the authority to waive any legal regulation that would impede the construction of border barriers, fences, or roads. It also limits legal challenges to such projects to those brought on constitutional grounds. The original version of REAL ID would have required the Secretary of Homeland Security to waive all laws that would impede barrier construction, and would have barred all court challenges. [LAWG 5/6/05]
The final bill includes an amendment from Sen. Barbara Mikulski (D-MD)--approved in the Senate's version of the bill--for a two- year waiver of the 66,000 annual cap on H-2B visas for returning low-skill seasonal workers. Maryland's seafood processing industry, which relies on foreign workers, lobbied heavily for that amendment. Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-TN) inserted a line in the final bill giving 10,500 visas to Australian guest workers in high-skill jobs. Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-TX) added a provision to provide up to 50,000 visas for foreign nurses and physical therapists and their family members, by reassigning visas which were left unused between 2001 and 2004-- though apparently drafting errors have left that provision in doubt. Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS) added a measure eliminating an annual cap of 1,000 on asylum grants for people (primarily from China) who claim persecution based on forced population control policies. [Investor's Business Daily 5/6/05; AP 5/4/05]
On May 7 hundreds of immigrants and supporters protested the passage of REAL ID in Rockville, Maryland. Maryland is one of 10 states that don't require driver's license applicants to prove they are in the US legally. [AP 5/7/05]
Senators John McCain (R-AZ) and Edward Kennedy (D-MA) plan to unveil a bipartisan immigration reform plan during the week of May 9. The plan is likely to include provisions for allowing some undocumented immigrants to apply for permanent residency, while also including measures tightening immigration and border enforcement and penalizing employers for hiring undocumented workers. [Arizona Republic (Phoenix) 5/6/05]
"REAL ID" APPROVED
On May 5, the House of Representatives voted 368-58 to approve the final version of an emergency supplemental appropriations bill, which includes a series of anti-immigrant measures originally introduced as the REAL ID Act [see INB 2/12/05, 4/3/05, 4/24/05]. The appropriations bill assigns about $76 billion for military operations, $656 million for tsunami relief, $4.2 billion for foreign aid and $635 million for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) bureaus of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customs and Border Protection (CBP). About $455 million goes for ICE to hire 50 criminal investigators and 168 immigration enforcement agents and deportation officers, and to obtain 1,950 additional detention beds. About $177 million goes to CBP to allow that agency to hire, train, equip and support 500 Border Patrol agents.
Although the Senate voted 99-0 on Apr. 21 for a version of the appropriations bill which excluded REAL ID, Senate leaders agreed in negotiations on May 3 to accept most of the REAL ID Act provisions in the final bill, supposedly in exchange for support of future immigration reform measures. The Senate is expected to approve the final version of the appropriations bill when it resumes sessions during the week of May 9.
The final bill requires applicants for state driver's licenses to show proof of citizenship or legal residency, document a home address and provide a photo ID. State motor vehicle departments would have to verify the documents using federal databases. States would have three years to comply with these requirements. If a state didn't comply, its licenses couldn't be used for federal identification purposes, such as boarding planes or entering federal buildings. [Associated Press 5/6/05; Los Angeles Times 5/6/05; Investor's Business Daily 5/6/05; Miami Herald 5/6/05; GovExec.com 5/5/05]
Some of the bill's controversial asylum provisions were modified in the final version. As passed, the Real ID Act will require applicants for asylum to prove that their race, religion, national origin, political opinion or membership in a particular social group constituted "at least one central reason" for their persecution. Current law requires applicants show that their persecution was based "at least in part" on one of these factors; the original version of REAL ID would have required applicants to prove that one of these factors was "a central reason" for their persecution.
Taken out of the final version of the bill were provisions eliminating stays of removal (which would have allowed asylum seekers to be deported while their cases are on appeal to federal court), giving bail bondspeople unprecedented power to detain immigrants in removal proceedings, and restricting judicial review of credibility determinations by immigration authorities. In a positive development, the Real ID Act removes the annual cap--presently 10,000--on the number of asylees who can adjust their status to permanent residency. [Immigration Equality 5/5/05; Latin America Working Group 5/6/05; ILW.com 5/6/05; Congressional Quarterly 5/4/05]
REAL ID gives the Secretary of Homeland Security the authority to waive any legal regulation that would impede the construction of border barriers, fences, or roads. It also limits legal challenges to such projects to those brought on constitutional grounds. The original version of REAL ID would have required the Secretary of Homeland Security to waive all laws that would impede barrier construction, and would have barred all court challenges. [LAWG 5/6/05]
The final bill includes an amendment from Sen. Barbara Mikulski (D-MD)--approved in the Senate's version of the bill--for a two- year waiver of the 66,000 annual cap on H-2B visas for returning low-skill seasonal workers. Maryland's seafood processing industry, which relies on foreign workers, lobbied heavily for that amendment. Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-TN) inserted a line in the final bill giving 10,500 visas to Australian guest workers in high-skill jobs. Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-TX) added a provision to provide up to 50,000 visas for foreign nurses and physical therapists and their family members, by reassigning visas which were left unused between 2001 and 2004-- though apparently drafting errors have left that provision in doubt. Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS) added a measure eliminating an annual cap of 1,000 on asylum grants for people (primarily from China) who claim persecution based on forced population control policies. [Investor's Business Daily 5/6/05; AP 5/4/05]
On May 7 hundreds of immigrants and supporters protested the passage of REAL ID in Rockville, Maryland. Maryland is one of 10 states that don't require driver's license applicants to prove they are in the US legally. [AP 5/7/05]
Senators John McCain (R-AZ) and Edward Kennedy (D-MA) plan to unveil a bipartisan immigration reform plan during the week of May 9. The plan is likely to include provisions for allowing some undocumented immigrants to apply for permanent residency, while also including measures tightening immigration and border enforcement and penalizing employers for hiring undocumented workers. [Arizona Republic (Phoenix) 5/6/05]
Immigration News Briefs (INB), a weekly English-language summary of US immigration news, is forwarded out to the email list of the Coalition for the Human Rights of Immigrants (CHRI). e-mail: nicajg@panix.com
|